The 10 Most Rated Mayors in the U.S.—And What Citizens Are Saying
At CitizensRatings.com, we believe that local leadership deserves the same level of scrutiny and praise as national politics. Mayors often have the most direct impact on everyday life—from public safety to sanitation, infrastructure to innovation. And thanks to thousands of reviews from everyday citizens, we’ve compiled a list of the 10 most rated mayors in the United States—along with the candid feedback citizens are sharing.
These leaders have sparked public dialogue—some for their inspiring leadership, others for controversial decisions. Either way, they’ve driven engagement, and that’s what democracy thrives on.
1. Eric Adams – New York City, NY
Top Issues: Crime, homelessness, transportation
What Citizens Are Saying: Reviews are mixed. Supporters say he’s taken bold stances on public safety and economic recovery, while critics argue his policies haven’t effectively reduced crime or supported housing for all.
2. Karen Bass – Los Angeles, CA
Top Issues: Affordable housing, homelessness, policing reform
What Citizens Are Saying: Citizens applaud her empathetic tone and strong housing plans. Some reviewers, however, express concern over the pace of visible change since she took office.
3. Lori Lightfoot (Former Mayor) – Chicago, IL
Top Issues: Crime, education, community outreach
What Citizens Are Saying: Lightfoot’s tenure remains one of the most reviewed, even after leaving office. Her leadership style received both praise for accessibility and criticism for strained relations with unions.
4. Sylvester Turner – Houston, TX
Top Issues: Budget management, disaster preparedness, infrastructure
What Citizens Are Saying: He’s lauded for stable financial management and his hurricane response. Some feel more transparency is needed in city contracts and environmental policies.
5. Michelle Wu – Boston, MA
Top Issues: Public transit, green policies, housing equity
What Citizens Are Saying: Her fresh approach and commitment to climate resilience have earned high marks. A few reviews question whether her progressive policies are feasible long-term.
6. Francis Suarez – Miami, FL
Top Issues: Crypto innovation, city branding, affordability
What Citizens Are Saying: Widely popular for putting Miami on the map as a tech-forward city, though residents voice concern about rising costs and the focus on optics over substance.
7. London Breed – San Francisco, CA
Top Issues: Drug crisis, homelessness, economic recovery
What Citizens Are Saying: Citizens appreciate her candid communication style. Many reviews call for stronger action on public health crises and crime management.
8. LaToya Cantrell – New Orleans, LA
Top Issues: Crime, city maintenance, tourism
What Citizens Are Saying: Reviewers note strong community ties but also point to challenges in managing crime and infrastructure. A polarizing figure, drawing both deep loyalty and fierce critique.
9. Andre Dickens – Atlanta, GA
Top Issues: Housing, education, city expansion
What Citizens Are Saying: Considered approachable and energetic. Citizens say he listens well and has potential, but some are eager to see more action behind his promises.
10. Tishaura Jones – St. Louis, MO
Top Issues: Gun violence, racial equity, public health
What Citizens Are Saying: Celebrated for progressive values and transparency, but citizens warn that big challenges like safety and infrastructure remain pressing.
The road to better education begins with honest reflection.
What These Reviews Tell Us
From these ten mayors, a clear message emerges: citizens are watching—and speaking up. Through CitizensRatings.com, they’re holding leaders accountable, highlighting what’s working, and voicing concerns where improvements are needed. The most rated mayors aren’t necessarily the best or worst—but they are the most talked about, and that visibility is the first step toward real change.
Want your voice to be heard?
Visit CitizensRatings.com and leave a review for your mayor or local official today. Your opinion is public power.
Related Blogs